Changes in the Rate of Some Rare Neonatal Outcomes After the Implementation of the Health System Reform Plan in Iran: A 70-Month Case Study of an Educational Hospital Research

AUTHORS

Parvaneh Sadeghi-Moghaddam ORCID 1 , Azadeh Asgarian ORCID 2 , Mohammad Aghaali ORCID 3 , *

1 Department of Pediatrics, Qom University of Medical Sciences, Qom, Iran

2 Qom University of Medical Sciences, Qom, Iran

3 Department of Epidemiology, School of Health, Qom University of Medical Sciences, Qom, Iran

How to Cite: Sadeghi-Moghaddam P, Asgarian A, Aghaali M. Changes in the Rate of Some Rare Neonatal Outcomes After the Implementation of the Health System Reform Plan in Iran: A 70-Month Case Study of an Educational Hospital Research. Shiraz E-Med J. 2021;22(7):e104897. doi: 10.5812/semj.104897.

ARTICLE INFORMATION

Shiraz E-Medical Journal: 22 (7); e104897
Published Online: November 30, 2020
Article Type: Research Article
Received: May 12, 2020
Revised: June 29, 2020
Accepted: June 30, 2020
Crossmark
Crossmark
CHECKING
READ FULL TEXT

Abstract

Background: The health system reform plan (HSRP) was launched in Iran on 15 May 2014, with three approaches to protect people from the financial system, create equity in access to health services, and improve the quality of services.

Objectives: The present study aimed at investigating the changes in the rate of some rare neonatal outcomes after the implementation of HSRP in Iran.

Methods: The present cross-sectional study was conducted in Izadi Hospital in Qom Province, in which 52,817 vaginal delivery and cesarean sections were evaluated for the incidence of complications from 15 June 2011 to 15 April 2017. The complications included hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, low Apgar score, cephalohematoma, clavicle fracture, the Erb palsy, and intracerebral hemorrhage. Complications were compared per 10,000 births before and after the implementation of the plan. Data were analyzed with SPSS software using t- and chi-squared tests.

Results: There was a significant increase after the implementation of HSRP compared to before that in the rate of complications per 10,000 vaginal deliveries for stage 2 hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (P = 0.001), birth with a low Apgar score (P < 0.001), cephalohematoma (P < 0.001), and clavicle fracture (P = 0.002). In the case of cesarean section, there was a significant increase in the 2 (P = 0.001) and 3 (P = 0.034) stages of hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy and birth with a low Apgar score (P < 0.001).

Conclusions: It can be concluded that HSRP could somewhat achieve its goals on the promotion of vaginal delivery. However, the implementation of the plan was associated with an increase in some minor neonatal complications.

1. Background

In May 2014, the Iranian Ministry of Health and Medical Education, along with the country’s move toward the Vision 2025, placed a set of programs called the health system reform plan (HSRP) on the agenda (1). The HSRP was implemented based on three main approaches as financial protection of people, creation of equity in access to healthcare services, and promotion of the quality of healthcare services. One of the goals of the HSRP was to reduce the rate of cesarean section in Iran (2). Despite the fact that vaginal delivery in most cases is the safest method for both the mother and the baby, before the implementation of the HSRP, both mothers and obstetrician-gynecologist showed more interest toward cesarean section, which led to a significant increase in the rate of this type of delivery in Iran (3).

Vaginal delivery usually has a shorter recovery period compared with cesarean section, and postpartum pain is lower with it; there is no anesthetic risk in vaginal delivery, and hospital stay is usually shorter (4, 5). The risk of developing respiratory distress and tachypnea is lower in neonates born by vaginal delivery. But, some other complications, such as bruising, limb swelling, the Erb palsy, and, in some cases, bone fractures threaten, or at least mostly threaten, infants born by vaginal delivery (6-8).

Results of a study by Demissie et al. (9), on more than 12 million births showed that vaginal delivery is associated with a higher risk of trauma in infants compared to cesarean section (2% vs. 1.1%).

Overall, the results of previous studies show that vaginal delivery and cesarean section have their advantages and disadvantages, and each can help the mother and the baby if performed properly. Therefore, keeping these aspects in mind, decisions on the application of which type should be made with caution.

Prior to the implementation of HSRP, factors such as fear of vaginal delivery and its pain, fear of neonatal complications, and the lack of access to physicians during labor increased the rate of cesarean section compared with vaginal delivery. Another issue was the support of physicians for cesarean section and tariff rates on this type of delivery that was not made on the vaginal type.

2. Objectives

Following the implementation of HSRP, with increasing the awareness of people of vaginal delivery, raising the tariffs on vaginal delivery in favor of physicians, guaranteeing access to physicians during labor, and providing the expected facilities, the rate of vaginal delivery increased. Since then, few studies are conducted on the changes in the prevalence of neonatal outcomes after the implementation of HSRP in Iran. The present study aimed at comparing the incidence of some rare birth complications associated with the increased rate of vaginal delivery before and after the HSRP implementation.

3. Methods

The present retrospective, observational study (before and after exposure) was conducted on all deliveries performed in Izadi Hospital in Qom, Iran, during 70 months, 35 months before, and 35 months after the implantation of HSRP. The total number of cesarean sections and vaginal deliveries performed from June 2011 to March 2017 was recorded according to registries at the medical records department. Also, the medical profiles of infants admitted during the study period were reviewed for the studied complications (stage 2 or 3 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, low Apgar score, cephalohematoma, clavicle fracture, the Erb palsy, intracranial hemorrhage, intubation, need for cardiac massage, and need for positive pressure ventilation and intubation). The medical profiles of infants with the studied complications were used to extract the required information, including the type of complication, gender, delivery type, delivery date, Apgar score, gestational age, and birth weight. Neonates with anomalies or metabolic or syndromic disorders were excluded from the study. As far as possible, babies transferred to other hospitals due to lack of beds were also followed up. Patients with one of the three complications of ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, the Erb palsy, and clavicle fracture were followed up by telephone, and the sustainability of their birth complications was investigated.

The collected data were analyzed with SPSS software version 25. The rate of complications was measured per 10,000 births in the two periods of before and after the implementation of HSRP; then, the outcomes were compared between the two groups. Statistical analysis was performed using chi-squared and the Fisher exact tests.

The present article is part of the results of a research project approved by the Ethics Committee of Biomedical Research, Qom University of Medical Sciences (ethical code: IR.MUQ.REC.1395.101); confidentiality of data was also guaranteed.

4. Results

Thirty-five months before launching HSRP, 23,932 deliveries were performed, of which 48.86% were cesarean section and 51.41% vaginal delivery. In the 35 months after the implementation of HSRP, 28,885 deliveries were performed, of which 40.5% were cesarean section and 59.5% vaginal delivery. After the implementation of HSRP, the rate of vaginal delivery significantly increased (Table 1).

Table 1. The Number of Births During the Study Period Based on the Type of Deliverya
Study PeriodCesarean SectionVaginal DeliveryTotal
Before the HSRP Implementation
June 2011-April 20123246 (47.2)3628 (52.8)6874
May 2012-April 20134137 (50.2)4103 (49.8)8240
May 2013-April 20144309 (48.9)45.9 (51.1)8818
Total11692 (48.9)12240(51.1)23932
After the HSRP Implementation
May 2014-April 20154248 (44)5412 (56)9660
May 2015-April 20163842 (38)6268 (62)10110
May 2016-March 20173648 (40)5467 (60)9115
Total11703 (40.5)17182 (59.5)28885

aValues are expressed as No. (%).

The medical profiles of 313 neonates with the studied complications were extracted, and totally, 492 complications were recorded, of which 87 cases belonged to pre-HSRP and 405 to post-HSRP. Of the 62 cases of the pre-HSRP, the type of delivery in eight infants was the vacuum-assisted vaginal delivery, and in one, the cesarean section due to full arrest. Of the 251 cases of the post-HSRP, 23 were born by vacuum extraction, and it was cesarean section due to full arrest in 31 (Table 2).

Table 2. Distribution of the Types of Delivery in Infants by the Studied Complications Based on the Examined Period
Type of DeliveryStudy PeriodTotal
Before the HSRP ImplementationAfter the HSRP Implementation
Vaginal delivery47150197
Vaginal delivery as vacuum extraction82331
Cesarean section due to failure to progress or fetal distress13132
Cesarean section for other reasons64753
Total62251313

Totally, 336 cases of complication were recorded during vaginal delivery and 156 during cesarean section (Table 3).

Table 3. The Number of Studied Complications Based on the Type of Delivery and the Examined Period
OutcomeTotalCesarean SectionVaginal Delivery
Before the HSRP ImplementationAfter the HSRP ImplementationBefore the HSRP ImplementationAfter the HSRP ImplementationBefore the HSRP ImplementationAfter the HSRP Implementation
Stage 2 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, y533113420
Stage 3 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, y4101733
Need for intubation834118716
Need for positive pressure ventilation1187439748
Need for cardiac massage4110744
Low Apgar score181164561460
Cephalohematoma1547021545
Clavicle fracture1035001035
The Erb palsy1116001116
Intracranial hemorrhage070304
Total863961114575251

Statistical analysis showed that after the implementation of HSRP, the rate of complications- i.e., stage 2 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, the need for positive pressure ventilation, low Apgar score, cephalohematoma, clavicle fracture- significantly increased per 10,000 natural births (Table 4). There were no significant differences in other complications between the two groups (Table 4).

Table 4. Comparison of Neonatal Complications Before and After the HSRP Implementation Based on the Type of Delivery
Type of DeliveryOutcomeBefore the HSRP Implementation (per 10,000 Deliveries)After the HSRP Implementation (per 10,000 Deliveries)P-Value
TotalStage 2 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy2.0911.42< 0.001
Stage 3 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy1.673.460.208
Need for intubation3.3411.770.001
Need for positive pressure ventilation4.630.12< 0.001
Need for cardiac massage1.673.810.141
Low Apgar score7.5240.16< 0.001
Cephalohematoma6.2716.27<0.001
Clavicle fracture4.1812.120.002
The Erb palsy4.65.540.633
Intracranial hemorrhage02.420.016
Vaginal deliveryStage 2 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy3.2711.640.013
Stage 3 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy2.451.750.676
Need for intubation5.729.310.277
Need for positive pressure ventilation5.7227.94< 0.001
Need for cardiac massage3.272.330.63
Low Apgar score11.4434.92< 0.001
Cephalohematoma12.2526.190.009
Clavicle fracture8.1720.370.008
The Erb palsy8.999.31.928
Intracranial hemorrhage02.330.091
Cesarean SectionStage 2 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy0.8611.11< 0.001
Stage 3 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy0.865.980.034
Need for intubation0.8615.38< 0.001
Need for positive pressure ventilation3.4233.32< 0.001
Need for cardiac massage05.98< 0.001
Low Apgar score3.4247.85< 0.001
Cephalohematoma01.710.157
Intracranial hemorrhage02.560.083

In the case of cesarean section, there was a significant increase in the incidence of stage 2 ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, need for intubation, need for ventilation with positive pressure, need for cardiac massage, and low Apgar score after the implementation of HSRP (Table 4).

According to the records, five and one cases of subgaleal bleeding occurred after and before the HSRP implementation, respectively. Facial nerve palsy, femoral fracture, right arm fracture, and depressed skull fracture were also reported in each case after the HSRP implementation, but none of them were observed before launching HSRP.

A total of 83 patients with one of the three complications of ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, the Erb palsy, and clavicle fracture were followed up by telephone for the sustainability of complications. The family of 21 infants did not respond. Among those responding, six infants with ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy developed cerebral palsy, of which three belonged to the pre-HSRP period and three others to the post-HSRP. Of the four infants developing persistent outcomes of the Erb palsy, three belonged to the pre-HSRP and one to the post-HSRP.

The number of complications per 10,000 births was evaluated in six-month intervals, and the results showed that after the implementation of HSRP, the number of complications increased and the increasing trend continued until 2016, but then the number of complications followed a declining trend (Figure 1).

Figure 1. The trend of the studied complications incidence per 10,000 births in six-month intervals, based on the type of delivery

5. Discussion

The present study addressed the impact of HSRP implementation on some rare birth complications. The study results showed that after the implementation of HSRP, the rate of natural births in the state hospitals significantly increased. Previous studies in this area also show increased natural birth rates in state hospitals after the HSRP implementation (10). However, some studies show that in private hospitals, the prevalence of cesarean delivery increased after launching the HSRP (10).

The present study showed that some of the studied complications- i.e., ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, low Apgar score, cephalic hematoma, and clavicle fracture, increased significantly after the HSRP implementation. However, the overall incidence of ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy in the studied hospital (1.8 per 1,000 births) was similar to those reported in other studies from developed countries (1.3 - 1.7 per 1,000 births) (11). In African countries, the incidence of ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy is estimated at 4.8% - 6.8% (12).

The authors’ previous study in Qom showed that the decreased rate of cesarean section was mostly attributed to emergency cesarean delivery (13). Another study in Shush City, Iran, showed a significant decrease in the causes of cesarean section- i.e., maternal pelvis-fetal head mismatch, meconium excretion, etc., after the HSRP implementation (2). It means that the gynecologists, after the implementation of HSRP, gave a greater chance of natural birth, and their decision on cesarean section was made with more delay. It could be one of the causes of an increase in some complications, such as the Erb palsy, ischemic-hypoxic encephalopathy, birth with a low Apgar score, and clavicle fracture.

In Norway, the results of a large clinical trial (2000) showed that the tendency of physicians toward cesarean delivery was greater in breech cases. Subsequently, in a study comparing birth complications between two periods, the results showed that during periods in which physicians had a greater tendency toward vaginal delivery in breach cases, the incidence of the low Apgar score and neonatal death was also higher (14).

Results of a study conducted in a hospital in Tehran, Iran, showed that the rate of birth injury in vaginal delivery was higher than that of emergency cesarean section (4.16% vs. 2.71%) (3).

The results of the study by Liu et al. (15), showed that the incidence of neonatal sepsis and umbilical cord blood acidosis was higher in twins born by vaginal delivery compared with their counterparts born by cesarean section.

A study conducted in Kurdistan Province, Iran, evaluated the viewpoint of healthcare service providers on the Vaginal Delivery Promotion Package in HSRP and the results showed that the main disadvantage the healthcare service providers- i.e., specialists and midwives, worried about was the increased maternal complications due to excessive emphasis on vaginal delivery (16).

Another change occurred after the implementation of HSRP was an increase in the number of vaginal delivery due to its free franchise, which consequently increased the workload of hospital personnel and may also affect the incidence of the studied complications.

In the present study, the number of complications per 10,000 births was studied in six-month intervals. The result showed that after the implementation of HSRP, the number of complications increased, and the trend continued until 2016; but afterward, the number of complications followed a declining trend. Two reasons can justify this behavior; first, the project implementation problems were gradually identified and resolved, and the rate of complications decreased afterward; second, increased experiences of specialists and midwives in the implementation of protocols and management of patients who mostly underwent cesarean section prior to HSRP, while vaginal delivery was advised to them after HSRP.

5.1. Limitation

According to the type of study, it was not possible to evaluate all variables affecting the desired outcomes in the present study. The study was conducted in a single-center, and the manner of implementing the protocols in the center can affect the studied complications. Evaluation of the overall effect of HSRP requires a comprehensive review of the plan, such as examining its cost-effectiveness and comparing other aspects of the plan, such as the impact on maternal complications, long-term infantile complications, etc.

5.2. Conclusions

The HSRP seems to be approached its goals in the promotion of vaginal delivery, but the results of the present study showed that the implementation of HSRP was accompanied by an increase in the number of some rare birth complications. It seems that in order to promote vaginal delivery, alongside the goals of HSRP, more attention should be paid to women’s knowledge of assisted vaginal delivery- e g, vacuum extraction.

Acknowledgements

Footnotes

References

  • 1.

    Esmailzadeh H, Rajabi F, Rostamigooran N, Majdzadeh R. Iran health system reform plan methodology. Iran J Public Health. 2013;42(Supple1):13-7. [PubMed: 23865010]. [PubMed Central: PMC3712604].

  • 2.

    Seidali ANN. [Assessment of changes in cesarean indications before and after the implementation of health sector evolution plan in pregnant women referred to Nezam-Mafi hospital, Shoush, Khoozestan province in 2013-2014]. Pejouhandeh. 2016;10(6):315-9. Persian.

  • 3.

    Khooshideh M, Mirzarahimi T. [The comparison of maternal and neonatal outcomes of normal vaginal delivery versus unplanned cesarean section delivery]. J Ardabil Univ Medi Sci. 2017;17(1):122-32. Persian.

  • 4.

    Loke AY, Davies L, Li SF. Factors influencing the decision that women make on their mode of delivery: the Health Belief Model. BMC Health Serv Res. 2015;15:274. doi: 10.1186/s12913-015-0931-z. [PubMed: 26188472]. [PubMed Central: PMC4506759].

  • 5.

    Sadeghi-Moghaddam P, Arjmandnia M, Shokrollahi M, Aghaali M. Does training improve compliance with hand hygiene and decrease infections in the neonatal intensive care unit? A prospective study. J Neonatal Perinatal Med. 2015;8(3):221-5. doi: 10.3233/NPM-15915001. [PubMed: 26485556].

  • 6.

    Pasupathy D, Smith GC. Neonatal outcomes with caesarean delivery at term. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2008;93(3):F174-5. doi: 10.1136/adc.2007.135152. [PubMed: 18426923].

  • 7.

    Aghaali M, Sadeghi-Moghaddam P, Khodakarim S. Predictive model for the cure rate of NICU admitted preterm neonates: the mixture cure model. J Pediatr Neonat Individ Med. 2019;9(1). e090101.

  • 8.

    Sadeghi Moghaddam P, Aghaali M. Survival of 798 Low Birth Weight Infants According to Birth Weight and Gestational Age. Shiraz E-Med J. 2015;16(11-12). doi: 10.17795/semj31761.

  • 9.

    Demissie K, Rhoads GG, Smulian JC, Balasubramanian BA, Gandhi K, Joseph KS, et al. Operative vaginal delivery and neonatal and infant adverse outcomes: population based retrospective analysis. BMJ. 2004;329(7456):24-9. doi: 10.1136/bmj.329.7456.24. [PubMed: 15231617]. [PubMed Central: PMC443446].

  • 10.

    Jabbari A, Yarmohamadian MH, Hadian M. Iran's Struggling Health System: An Increase in Natural Childbirth: A Case Study. Int J Prev Med. 2018;9:47. doi: 10.4103/ijpvm.IJPVM_82_16. [PubMed: 29899885]. [PubMed Central: PMC5981228].

  • 11.

    Kurinczuk JJ, White-Koning M, Badawi N. Epidemiology of neonatal encephalopathy and hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy. Early Hum Dev. 2010;86(6):329-38. doi: 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2010.05.010. [PubMed: 20554402].

  • 12.

    Lee AC, Kozuki N, Blencowe H, Vos T, Bahalim A, Darmstadt GL, et al. Intrapartum-related neonatal encephalopathy incidence and impairment at regional and global levels for 2010 with trends from 1990. Pediatr Res. 2013;74 Suppl 1:50-72. doi: 10.1038/pr.2013.206. [PubMed: 24366463]. [PubMed Central: PMC3873711].

  • 13.

    Sadeghi-moghadam P, Asgarian A, Tondari M, Toosi H, Aghaali M. The Effect of Health System Reform Plan on Neonatal Outcomes: A Case Study in an Educational Hospital, 2011-2016, (Iran). Qom Univ Med Sci J. 2018;12(6):48-54. doi: 10.29252/qums.12.6.48.

  • 14.

    Vistad I, Klungsoyr K, Albrechtsen S, Skjeldestad FE. Neonatal outcome of singleton term breech deliveries in Norway from 1991 to 2011. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2015;94(9):997-1004. doi: 10.1111/aogs.12684. [PubMed: 26037909].

  • 15.

    Liu AL, Yung WK, Yeung HN, Lai SF, Lam MT, Lai FK, et al. Factors influencing the mode of delivery and associated pregnancy outcomes for twins: a retrospective cohort study in a public hospital. Hong Kong Med J. 2012;18(2):99-107. [PubMed: 22477732].

  • 16.

    Moradi GH, Farhadifar F, Piroozi B, Mohamadi B. [An assessment of promoting natural childbirth package in health reform plan from the opinion of stakeholders in Hospitals of Kurdistan University of Medical Science, 2015]. Hakim Res J. 2016;19(2):103-10. Persian.

  • Copyright © 2020, Author(s). This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits copy and redistribute the material just in noncommercial usages, provided the original work is properly cited.
    COMMENTS

    LEAVE A COMMENT HERE: